Khalid Maqbool criticises PPP’s opposition to new units, accusing it of protecting its political & financial interests
Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) Chairman and Federal Minister for Education Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui addressing media at the party’s Bahadurabad headquarters. Photo: MQM/X
KARACHI:
Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) Chairman and Education Minister Dr Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui on Thursday said his party had postponed its planned November 29 rally in support of new provinces due to security concerns, while reiterating its demand for administrative restructuring across Pakistan.
Addressing a press conference at the party’s Bahadurabad headquarters, Siddiqui said a new date for the demonstration would be announced after consultations within the party.
He maintained that provinces, like districts and divisions, were administrative units and should not be treated as the personal property of politicians.
“Just as districts and divisions are administrative units, provinces are administrative units too. We will not allow anyone to treat provinces as their personal estate,” he said.
Siddiqui said the creation of new provinces was a political matter that should be resolved through democratic means, adding that administrative structures needed to be expanded in line with population growth.
“The demand for new provinces, which once emerged from the urban areas of Sindh, is now a demand across the country,” he added.
The MQM-P chief maintained that his party was not seeking the creation of provinces on linguistic grounds but on the basis of population distribution. He said the debate over administrative restructuring should take place in parliament and through constitutional forums rather than being turned into a street confrontation.
Drawing a parallel with the expansion of districts and divisions over the past several decades, he questioned why provinces could not undergo similar administrative restructuring. He said the number of districts and divisions had increased over the past 50 to 60 years, arguing that provinces served the same administrative purpose.
Addressing criticism of the demand, Siddiqui said threats would not deter his party and that it was willing to consider arguments based on reason. “Threats do not work on us. If there is a logical argument, we will accept it and understand it,” he said.
He also criticised what he described as threats directed at residents of Sindh’s urban areas, saying they could not be intimidated.
“The people of Sindh’s urban areas are not bonded peasants who can be threatened,” he said, adding that the demand for new provinces across the country “cannot be equated with treason”.
Criticism of PPP
Siddiqui questioned the Pakistan Peoples Party’s opposition to the creation of new provinces, accusing it of applying different political standards in different parts of the country.
Referring to the 1970 general elections, he questioned the PPP’s claim to being a national party, arguing that it had lacked representation in 55% of the country at the time. He further alleged that the party had only linguistic roots.
He said the PPP had formed a government at the Centre despite not having a majority in most provinces, and questioned why it had not implemented the quota system in Punjab, where it had secured a majority in the 1970 elections.
The MQM-P chairman also challenged PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari to explain why the party had singled out Karachi, Hyderabad, Mirpurkhas and Nawabshah in its opposition to the creation of new provinces.
He questioned whether the PPP’s concerns were linked to the possibility of losing political control over these urban centres and made references to Uzair Baloch, Janu Arain and Qadir Magsi while questioning who would be involved in the alleged violence.
“Is this a threat?” Siddiqui asked, urging the authorities to take notice of what he described as provocation. He also called on the judiciary to take suo motu notice of the matter.
He argued that the PPP opposed new administrative units because it feared losing control over areas that contributed more than 98% of Sindh’s revenue. He alleged that the provincial budget was not being spent proportionately in the areas generating the bulk of the province’s economic activity.
“Sindh’s urban areas have the strongest arguments in favour of new provinces based on historical, political, legal, constitutional, economic and societal realities,” he said.
Siddiqui said questions would eventually be raised about the distribution of the legitimate revenue generated by Sindh’s urban areas, followed by scrutiny of other alleged sources of income, including corruption, crime and land grabbing, which he claimed accounted for more than twice the province’s declared revenue.
Without naming the Bhutto family directly, he criticised what he described as the concentration of wealth within a single political family, claiming its assets were worth more than Rs50,000-60,000 billion. He described the concentration of such wealth as an existential threat to the country and regretted that it had not translated into development even in Larkana, the PPP’s political stronghold.
Citing the provincial Planning and Development Department, Siddiqui said poverty had declined in all provinces except Sindh. He questioned why the country’s wealthiest province continued to experience widespread deprivation.
“Sindh also has the highest number of schools and yet the worst literacy rate,” he said.
He also criticised the PPP over the controversial language bill introduced by the party in the provincial assembly in the past, urging it to learn from its previous mistakes and abandon what he described as divisive politics.
Siddiqui further alleged that the PPP had legitimate electoral support only in rural Sindh, while its governments elsewhere in the country had come through what he called the system’s intervention.
Census and constitutional mechanism
Turning to the 2023 census, Siddiqui accused the provincial government of undercounting Karachi’s population, arguing that the city’s high-rise buildings had not been properly accounted for.
Citing recognition of Karachi’s population by the president and the then chief justice in 2008, he questioned the subsequent reduction reflected in the latest census figures.
He said the political will of 65% of Sindh’s urban population was being ignored in the debate over the creation of new provinces, adding that Karachi and other urban centres had sufficient economic resources to finance new administrative units.
“We will even give it to those who fall short [in the budget],” he said.
The MQM-P chief also questioned the constitutional mechanism for creating new provinces, arguing that provincial assemblies should not have the authority to determine the division of existing provinces when they had a conflict of interest in the matter.
He maintained that the federal government should instead have the authority to initiate the process of administrative restructuring.
“We respect your mandate but you should refrain from provocations against us just because we are in favour of administrative division of Sindh,” Siddiqui said, addressing Bilawal.
