Bilawal’s speech raises more questions about FCC

The Federal Constitutional Court building. Photo: File


ISLAMABAD:

PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s remarks about the post-27th amendment judiciary have raised serious doubts about the legitimacy of the judicial system, especially the newly established Federal Constitutional Court (FCC).

Bilawal, who was himself a strong supporter of establishing the FCC, is now saying that the 27th amendment was passed through “brute majority” rather than through consensus/mutual agreement.

He says the FCC was an aspiration under the Charter of Democracy, but can it function effectively if it enjoys the confidence of the government alone and not the opposition.

PTI General Secretary Salman Akram Raja, while talking to The Express Tribune, welcomed Bilawal’s statement questioning Supreme Court judgements, such as giving the PTI reserved seats to other parties and depriving the PTI of its election symbol.

He said what Bilawal said today has been obvious to every political observer for the last four years. Even his party—the PPP—has been a beneficiary of it, he added. Raja said he expected Bilawal to stand with the opposition against the plundering of Parliament as well as the judicial system.

The PTI leader lamented that thousands of PTI workers, including party founder Imran Khan and his wife, Bushra Bibi, have been victims of the assault on Pakistan’s political system.

Pakistan Bar Council (PBC) executive member Barrister Salahuddin Ahmed said Bilawal strongly supported both the 26th and 27th Amendments and argued the creation of the FCC would protect constitutional rights and especially the interests of smaller provinces.

“Similarly, the PPP itself filed a review petition against the original Supreme Court decision awarding reserved seats to the PTI, arguing that those seats should be taken away from the PTI and awarded to the other parties (including the PPP,” he added.

“However, in only one year, he has realised the death blow these amendments have dealt to the independence of judiciary and constitutional principles as well as the profoundly undemocratic nature of the Supreme Court’s review judgment in the reserved seats case,” he added.

Barrister Ahmed said the PPP and many segments of the PML-N to are now belatedly realising that to “keep on feeding a crocodile in the hope it eats you last is not a winning strategy”

He said even if the 26th and 27th amendments were eventually rolled back, it would take decades to repair the damage already done. “And the judges who cheered on this process for petty gains will have to live with that realisation for years,” he added.

Former additional attorney general Waqar Rana regretted that the FCC has failed to uphold the Constitution as it neither has the capacity nor courage. “The constitutional court envisaged by the Charter of Democracy was quite different from the one which exists now,” he said.

Rana said Bilawal showed that he understood the principles his mother sacrificed her life for.

“It is a tough and hard journey as the road to true democracy is long and thorny. Bilawal must show perseverance, courage and conviction which were the traits of her mother. Only then will he become a people’s leader—a hope for the future,” he said.

Barrister Asad Rahim Khan said the PPP has disowned the 27th Amendment—and, by extension, the creation of the FCC—after just one year, despite being its major coauthor. The first step towards solving a problem is acknowledging there is one.

Khan said now actual, concrete steps will matter far more than statements and press conferences.

“Will the PPP’s governor [in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa] release [PTI’s] Taimur Jhagra, arrested without cause, the exact same time this admission was aired? Will it return the reserved seats it has now acknowledged it has zero right to cling on to?

“Will it pursue the release of political prisoners whose incarceration it calls unjust: Imran Khan, Ali Wazir, Mahrang Baloch, Imaan Mazari, Ali Hadi Chattha, Yasmin Rashid, and so many more. There can be no ‘political reset’, not even the start of one, without all of the above,” he added.

Abid Saqi advocate also welcomed Bilawal statement. However he stated that the system could only survive when state structure were decolonized.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *